MISTEC Day 4

07/24/2026Natalie Morgenstern

Warm-up with the UQAM percussion team on the Baschet Brothers instruments (instrumentarium). Very very cool! You can hit these things anywhere and everywhere—you can even put them on your head for different reverberation: https://youtu.be/B4YesiVwo8Y?si=pBnRD5zsHOinchKL

Yasumasa Yamaguchi: Reconsidering cultural inclusivity in Ai

  • Think about Ai in East Asian as digital colonisation.

  • Ai as data training—who can use it, and what kind of music can it support?

  • The data Ais are trained on are western-centric musics.

  • The Western model of music permeates university entrance exams worldwide: piano and voice in traditional Western-based styles.

  • When music becomes data: notes and rhythm are easy to translate from living sounds to digital

  • Historical and embodied practice is much harder to digify

  • Need to ask ourselves what is kept and found in computer data, and what is left behind

  • Musical training data: 94.3% Western, 5.7% Non-Western

  • Ai learns from this

  • Ai has trouble preserving oral, flexible pitch, local tuning, traditional instruments, and cultural meaning

  • Ai tends to simplify the cultural musics that it tries to replicate

  • Teachers need to use Ai more carefully to ensure musical diversity, critical literacy, and community collaboration

Posters

Susie (Victoria University): What is the purpose of music education in Australia? Autoethnographic study

  • Why do we have to learn notation?

  • Whose music matters?

  • What music knowledges are we asking our students to leave at the door?

Katie (LaTrobe): What makes a class ready for musicking?

  • What can be done to prepare students for the class they are about to participate in? This is not wasted time!

Lisa: Feldenkreis practice

  • Instrumental learning is based on rote repetition, which develops and exacerbates injury. It is based on a computer-based learning model.

Ana (Lisbon): Soundscapes to Sonotopia

Sarah (Brussels)

  • Primary school teachers forced to teach music who say they won't/can't

  • Methodology of self-confrontation

Rachel, Brad and James: Interrogating 'quality' in music education programs

  • What does quality mean?

  • Does it only represent cultural capital?

  • Robert Walker: Beethoven or Britney: https://search.informit.org/doi/abs/10.3316/INFORMIT.443186202990307

  • Aesthetic-Hierarchical Model (quality as disciplined musical literacy and cultural cultivation: Western art music)

  • Structural-Continuity Model (music practice embedded in a history of power)

  • Critical-Pluralist Model (Music is the birthright of every child. Quality as culturally responsive, context-driven musical learning)

  • Other words to use instead of quality: significant musical education, or comprehensive musical education

  • 'Quality' means something different to government bodies, policy makers, teachers, principals, parents, and students.

  • See 'Music Counts' (Canadian site) for language use.

Quebec music resources

  • Presentation slides:

    https://canva.link/gy2ao92rt3gryx9

  • Site resources: https://smcq.qc.ca/

  • Select: Youth, Educational platform, create an account, subscribe

  • Stacks of amazing free resources here!

  • Including a BandLab activities including listening, interpreting, and creating

  • Listen, imagine, and describe

  • Concert Band arrangements with reflection sheets for students

  • Lots of interactive stuff

Notes:

Several people from different countries said that their pre-service teachers are sent off in pairs for their assignments. That this works very well because they can talk immediately with each other for comfort and feedback.